CHALLENGE!!!How much do they weigh? 2024

CJ reply :

Okay, There's been alot of good threads going on about how much fish weigh. I thought I would start a thread to see how good some of our members are at weight guestimation! I know down to the ounce how much each of these fish weighed. I believe you will see how deceiving a photo can be. So just for kicks! Take a shot at how much each of these fish weighed.

Sorry my photography skills aren't the best.

-HAWK- reply :

Bass #1

4.1lbs

Bass #2

4.4lbs

Bass #3

4.8lbs

Bass #4

5.6lbs

Kozak reply :

1: 6-02

2: 5-01

3: 5-10

4: 5-07

Eddie Munster reply :

Nice looking fish but I'm not going out on that limb. It's not that I don't want to be wrong; I just don't want to come off the wrong way.

The guesses here on the forums are kind of odd and inconsistent.

Assuming the female holding #3 is not 6' tall, I'd guess #3 is the smallest of the bunch (weight and size wise) 20" or less & < 5 lbs. The rest are hard to venture a guess without knowing how big of a guy you are.

paul. reply :

1 - 7.6 lbs.

2 - 8.1 lbs.

3 - 6.5 lbs.

4 - 9.3 lbs.

oh wait, i'm getting ahead of myself. that's y'all's future fishin' trips. ;D

teria, i deduct 1 pound from your catch for not smiling. could you please act a little more excited when you are holding a nice fish? smile girl, that's a good 'un. 8-)

Paul Roberts reply :

This is fun. No, I'm not guessing, except to say all fish are over 4lbs -I think.

Hawgcaller, do you have an inside line here??

CJ reply :

Eddie, you can't offend me. Please give it a shot. It'll be fun.

Hawgcaller, your too kind! I told Teria the same thing. The problem that day was she left her shades at the house (rookie mistake), the sun was frying her eyes. We gave her a spare hat to help out.

Okay, I'll help ya'll out a little bit. I am 5' 11" and weigh 150lbs. soakin' wet.

Eddie Munster reply :

Quote
Eddie, you can't offend me. Please give it a shot. It'll be fun.
Hawgcaller, your too kind! I told Teria the same thing. The problem that day was she left her shades at the house (rookie mistake), the sun was frying her eyes. We gave her a spare hat to help out.

Wasn't afraid of offending you; I'm with Paul Roberts in that I believe them to all be over 4lbs and most over 5lbs but then again, I believe mine to be as large as those you have pictured. That's what I meant by come off sounding the wrong way and that guessing seems to be inconsistent. 8-)

Eddie Munster reply :

BTW, I'm guessing your size to be approx 6'2" or just over and about 190-200lbs. Lemme know.

.dsaavedra. reply :

3.5

5.5

Mattlures reply :

They all look between 4 and 6 lbs. #3 is not the smallest

Paul Roberts reply :

#2 weighs the most.

#3 the least, followed by #4.

So lessee...

In order of size largest to smallest:

2, 1, 4, 3

CJ reply :

:-X.

Jake. reply :

5.5

4.75

5.25

Pond Hopper reply :

6-2

5-7

4-3

5-11

Paul Roberts reply :

Pondhopper, that one in your avatar has to go 12, (and your fingers weigh a pound each).

CJ reply :

Paul Roberts, why don't you give it a try? Your right about one thing.

Bassn Blvd reply :

7.2

6.7

6.1

7.8

Jimzee reply :

Alright CJ, I'll take a shot at 2. and 4. because I remember what 1. and 3. weighed when you posted them.

2.- 3.7 lbs.

4.- 4.1 lbs.

.dsaavedra. reply :

so CJ, when are you gonna tell us?

JayDub reply :

I say the order from largest to smallest is:

2, 4, 1, 3

And my weight guesses are:

1. 6 lbs

2. 7.5 lbs

3. 4.5 lbs

4. 6.5 lbs

CJ reply :

Quote
so CJ, when are you gonna tell us?

Not tonight.

I'm still waiting for someone to get close to atleast 3 of them. :

Heck, I guess I'm gonna have to give something to whoever can get the closest! How bout three brand new jigs or a brand new Rapala!

Kozak reply :

No one has even got close yet?

That's it, I'm changing all my guesses

1: 3.5lbs

2: 4lbs

3: 3lbs

4:3.75lbs

paul. reply :

Quote
Heck, I guess I'm gonna have to give something to whoever can get the closest! How bout three brand new jigs or a brand new Rapala!

o.k., now i'm gonna guess. ;D ;D ;D j/k buddy.

Muad Dib reply :

ok here are the guesses of the fish to the ounce!!!!

fish by weight

picture 2. 5.3 lbs

picture 1. 4.9 lbs

picture 3. 4.8 lbs

picture 4. 4.4 lbs

its either this. or its a trick question and they all way the same weight and number 3 could be the biggest!

senko_77 reply :

1: 7.2

2: 6.11

3: 6:15

4: 8.3

Mattlures reply :

The first and the last look the biggest but he is sticking them out HARD. 2 and 4 look the smallest but its the picture angle. They are all pretty close. probably within a pound of eachother and I still say her fish is not the smallest.

Eddie Munster reply :

CJ, how big are you and how much do you weigh? Can't guess without knowing that! Was I close with 6'2" 190-200lbs?

No one's close to three of them yet? I guess I was right about the inconsistent guessing. 8-)

Korea_Bassin reply :

Quote
Eddie, you can't offend me. Please give it a shot. It'll be fun.
Hawgcaller, your too kind! I told Teria the same thing. The problem that day was she left her shades at the house (rookie mistake), the sun was frying her eyes. We gave her a spare hat to help out.

Okay, I'll help ya'll out a little bit. I am 5' 11" and weigh 150lbs. soakin' wet.

Eddie Munster reply :

Thanks Korea; missed that.

Okay CJ; based on your size and experts' guesses of my fish....here we go:

1. 4lb 8oz

2. 4lb 5oz

3. 3lb 15oz

4. 4lb 9oz

rondef reply :

Here are my guesses:

6.8

5.7

5.2

8.6

garry77 reply :

Here's my feeble attempt:

1-5.8

2-6.5

3-4.8

4-5.2

Paul Roberts reply :

I can tell the northern guessers from the southern!

A Rapala!! Jigs!!!!!

5-3

5-12

3-14

4-2

mattm reply :

Guessing from pictures can make you look stupid.

Heres my shot

4lbs 10oz

6lbs 2oz

5lbs 8oz

3lbs 14oz

David P reply :

All look between 4-6lbs. The last one looks to have a big mouth, but looks rather skinny.

Low_Budget_Hooker reply :

All this # guessing is like watching a game show,lol

"I'd like to trade this in for what's behind curtain #2 Bob......"

CJ reply :

Quote
All this # guessing is like watching a game show,lol
"I'd like to trade this in for what's behind curtain #2 Bob......"

It's even more entertaining when you know the answers!

Eddie Munster reply :

Alright CJ, what's the real numbers?!

CJ reply :

I'll give em' tonight at 8:00 pm central time. I'll give ya'll a hint, everybody has missed atleast one fish by more than a pound. Some have missed a fish by as much as 3 lbs.

RobbyZ5001 reply :

#1- 6.5

#2- 5.2

#3- 4.5

#4-7.3

Bassn Blvd reply :

I changed #2. In order of the pictures..

7.2

6.7

6.1

7.8

MARSH MASTER reply :

1- 7.5

2- 6.8

3- 5

4- 6.2

FishinDaddy reply :

7.0

5.8

4.8

5.0

WTRDOG reply :

The third one looks to be around 115lbs...

CJ reply :

1. 5 lbs. even

2. 7 lbs. even

3. 3 lbs. 5 oz.

4. 5 lbs. 9 oz.

I took the difference of each guess/fish and added up the total score from the 4 fish. The lowest score won.

gary77, was the closest, on the average, to each fish's weight. Nice "feeble" attempt gary!

PM sent.

JayDub reply :

Hey, I was within about a pound on all of them. Good enough for me!

Teria reply :

Thanks for all the compliments on #3 fish. I sure thought it was bigger than 3lb 5oz. I think the scales were broke!

Paul Roberts reply :

Thanks CJ. That was fun.

Eddie Munster reply :

This was INDEED fun; with the wide variety of guesses and the actual numbers, I feel alot better about my fish now.

Again; great fish.

roadwarrior reply :

Late to the game...

It's much more fun when you have the actual weights to compare guesses!

8-)

HOIST-N-HAWGS reply :

24.11lbs for all of them OOOOOOOOOOPs seriously didn't realize the game was over >

1516

CHALLENGE!!!How much do they weigh? 2024

related Fishing Reports topic

previous topic

next topic

most viewed Fishing Reports topic