Need A New Reel (Shimano Or Lew's?) 2024
iamham3 reply :
I missed out on the $99 Curado G's at BPS last month but I still want a Shimano reel. I want a reel to fill the shallow to medium diving crankbait gap in my arsenal. I borrowed my brother's Curado BSF, and liked it ok. He's a diehard Shimano fan and suggested I look at the Chronarch 50MG, Curado'S D & BSF and some other Chronarchs I can't remember the model numbers for. After looking at Shimanos I got interested in the Scorpion's (to have something different--if they're good reels). I've been wanting a Lew's reel, and am leaning towards the BB1, BB1 Pro, or TP. I will eventually get a Shimano and a Lew's but can only afford 1 right now with $200 being my "limit". Any advice on which ones would suit my "needs" best?
I have 3 PQ's (that I have no problems with, one of the best deals in fishing at $69) and a Daiwa Tatula that I like a lot. Just want some other brands.
rbreedi1 reply :
Your gonna get different opinions. I personally like shimano but thats my taste in tackle and I've had both. The Curado E is an excellent reel that can be had for a good price used.
Delaware Valley Tackle reply :
If you have PQ's and like them but want to experiment, skip Lew's/ABU/Pflueger for now since they're all built on the same platform as the PQ. More Daiwas, Shimano, the new Pinnacle line, maybe a Quantum but I suggest staying in the upper end with them if you go that route.
bootytrain reply :
Scorpion 1000xt. They can be found for about $180 new.
guisingerevan reply :
Saving up to replace all my reels with Lew's BB1 Pros right now. I would highly recommend trying one out. It is extremely smooth, casts a mile, and hold a lot of line. Plus it is only 6.5oz
iamham3 reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 1:06 AM, bootytrain said:Scorpion 1000xt. They can be found for about $180 new.
Are there any issues with getting JDM reels worked on here if need be?
bootytrain reply :
I've never had to have any of my JDM reels worked on but the scorpion 1000xt is the JDM equivalent to the chronarch 50e. So any parts are interchangeable. Just watch out though, once you go Shimano 50 its hard to go back lol.
roadwarrior reply :
I think the best option is the new Curado I. However, if you want a smaller profile the
Curado 50E is one of my very favorite reels.
Delaware Valley Tackle reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 1:18 AM, iamham3 said:Are there any issues with getting JDM reels worked on here if need be?
No problem.
Arv reply :
Can't go wrong with either Imo. I like lews because I can find the tournament pro for 150-160 pretty consistently
Brian Needham reply :
I just orderd a BB1pro for my cranking set up........ Ron from valley sports had a really good price on it.
Dramer77 reply :
Gander mountain has curado's for 129
Wbeadlescomb reply :
Can't go wrong with a curado. The only difference I can tell in my chronarch is that it throws light baits better
mc6524 reply :
Just a thought, I can appreciate wanting a low profile, but I would suggest you look at the new curado I. Since you might want a slower sPeed, it comes in a 5.5:1 that works creat for crank baits. I also like the tatulas. Both are under $200,
eyedabassman reply :
Put me down for ANY of the Lew's reels!!!!!!!!! 
Fishing_Cory reply :
Can't go wrong with Lews! I own 8 I believe and about to get 5 more! Great products at awesome prices and outstanding customer service!
new2BC4bass reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 6:38 AM, Fishing_Cory said:Can't go wrong with Lews! I own 8 I believe and about to get 5 more! Great products at awesome prices and outstanding customer service!
If you aren't careful, you will catch up to me and my Daiwas. 
OP, another situation where you really can't go wrong. Have you considered a T3-1016H on sale at TW? I bought the last LH high speed one this morning, but there are still models for either hand in the 6.3:1 ratio. A used Chronarch 100B can be found for around $125 in good to excellent shape. Used Curado 50Es normally go for a bit more. Excellent little reels. Haven't used my Lews TP much because my middle grandson thinks it is his. 
It is a nice looking reel that casts very well. Have no experience with the G and newer Shimanos.
deaknh03 reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 1:06 AM, bootytrain said:Scorpion 1000xt. They can be found for about $180 new.
Where do you get them at that price?
bootytrain reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 7:32 AM, deaknh03 said:Where do you get them at that price?
http://global.rakuten.com/en/store/sanpei-japan/item/shima-024695/
FlipSide reply :
IMO you can't go wrong with Lews. But beware. You will just want more when you buy the first one
ABW reply :
BB1 Pro gets my vote
Basswhippa reply :
If you are going to get a Lews, get one of the older ones that was built by Shimano. Otherwise, just get a Shimano. The new Curado looks sweet. I predict there will be a lot of G's coming on sale soon once Shimano catches up with production on the I's.
Jay Ell Gee reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 2:08 AM, roadwarrior said:I think the best option is the new Curado I. However, if you want a smaller profile the
Curado 50E is one of my very favorite reels.
I have two of the Chronarch 50e's and my regular fishing buddy has a few Curado 50e's. they are built on the same frame and platform.
I picked up a new Curado I on release day and I will say that it is getting close to the profile of a 50 class reel. If you have picked up a new Chronarch Ci4+, it's essentially the same frame design (ergonomically), just a touch heavier at 7.2 oz. It is amazingly smooth and I would pick another up before my Chronarchs, though I love them, too!
I only have one Lews, a Tourney Mg 7.1, but I am thoroughly impressed with it. The BB1 pro is on my short list of reels that I wouldn't mind owning.
John G reply :
I just bought 3 Scorpions from Japan Tackle. A XT1000 and 2 XT1500's. The XT1000 is a better reel than the Curado 50E that I had IMHO. People say it's the same reel but I don't remember the Curado 50E that I had being as good a caster as the XT1000. Japan Tackle has the XT1000 for $199.00. To be honest, after using the XT1000, I wish that I would have bought 2 XT1000's and 1 XT1500 instead.
deaknh03 reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 8:00 AM, bootytrain said:http://global.rakuten.com/en/store/sanpei-japan/item/shima-024695/
I should have known, those guys have good stuff. The shipping is what stinks, I count that as part of the reel price, that reel is around $20 to ship.
iamham3 reply :
All of this is much needed, greatly appreciated advice.
Being advised that the Lew's are built on the same platform as my PQ's I can wait a little while before experimenting with one of those and go with a Shimano right now. I'm leaning towards the Scorpion XT1000, but have only received 2 responses favoring the Scorpion compared with many others suggesting Curados and Chronarchs. Are there any advantages in opting for the Japanese reel besides having something that's not as common? Any disadvantages?
Just trying to get a little more knowledge from more knowledgeable anglers than me before I pull the trigger. Fishing purchases in 2014 will be fewer and further between.
bootytrain reply :
Get the scorpion, if you don't like it you will have no problem selling it. But you will love it. The bearings are better on the scorpion vs its USDM counterpart chronarch 50. Plus you have finesse spool options that Lews doesn't.
John G reply :
The disadvantages in getting a Scorpion is no warranty support if you need it. There are no advantages in getting a Scorpion XT1000 IMHO. I got one because it's a great looking JDM 50 sized Shimano that is very affordable.
Basshammer reply :
Oh yea i have a bb1 pro lews and that is so smooth i can't put it down sometimes. I am sure the curado is just as good just personal preference.
iamham3 reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 5:51 PM, John G said:I just bought 3 Scorpions from Japan Tackle. A XT1000 and 2 XT1500's. The XT1000 is a better reel than the Curado 50E that I had IMHO. People say it's the same reel but I don't remember the Curado 50E that I had being as good a caster as the XT1000. Japan Tackle has the XT1000 for $199.00. To be honest, after using the XT1000, I wish that I would have bought 2 XT1000's and 1 XT1500 instead.
After having these reels for almost 2 months now do you still feel the same?
I was originally looking at buying the XT1000 for use with small to medium crankbaits, but am now looking at it for other uses (nothing heavy duty). Do you think it would be adequate as a reel that can cover a broad range of applications? Do you suggest the XT1500 for more versatility?
BasshunterJGH reply :
Lews TP!
deaknh03 reply :
On 5/28/2014 at 5:13 AM, iamham3 said:After having these reels for almost 2 months now do you still feel the same?
I was originally looking at buying the XT1000 for use with small to medium crankbaits, but am now looking at it for other uses (nothing heavy duty). Do you think it would be adequate as a reel that can cover a broad range of applications? Do you suggest the XT1500 for more versatility?
I have 1000xts,1500xts and would absolutely recommend them to you. I use a 1000xt for small jigs 1/4 and under as well as cranks up to 1/2 oz. I have it teamed with a med action rod. The 1500 is the next step up, I use it for topwater but it takes up where the 1000 left off..anything over 1/2 oz is perfect..mines paired with a m/h but its more heavy than med. It could be used with a heavy no problem. I also use the mg series and regular 1000 and 1500s, all superior reels.
John G reply :
On 5/28/2014 at 5:13 AM, iamham3 said:After having these reels for almost 2 months now do you still feel the same?
I was originally looking at buying the XT1000 for use with small to medium crankbaits, but am now looking at it for other uses (nothing heavy duty). Do you think it would be adequate as a reel that can cover a broad range of applications? Do you suggest the XT1500 for more versatility?
I sure do! I have a XT1000 on a top water rod and I will be throwing up to a 3/4oz Spook with it. I have the 1500-7 on my MBR843 for lighter T Rigs and I have the regular XT1500 on a Loomis CR723 for 1/2oz and under spinnerbaits. I may get another XT1000 to fill this role. I am getting another 1500-7 for my MBR844 for jigs and heavier T Rigs. What I found out since I got my Scorpions is that the handle on the XT1000 can accept 4 bearings and the 1500's cannot. The schematic for the 1500's show that the handle has 1 bearing and 1 bushing in each knob but it does not. At least mine do not. My 1500 handles can only accept 1 bearing in each knob. My 1500-7 now sports an 85mm ZPI handle with Power Grip II Knobs and my other Scorpions will too eventually.The Scorpions are very practical, great quality, Japanese Made Shimano's that will serve me well and I just wish that I had more of them.
fisherrw reply :
love my lews bb1 pro!
stkbassn reply :
On 4/9/2014 at 12:37 AM, iamham3 said:I missed out on the $99 Curado G's at BPS last month but I still want a Shimano reel. I want a reel to fill the shallow to medium diving crankbait gap in my arsenal. I borrowed my brother's Curado BSF, and liked it ok. He's a diehard Shimano fan and suggested I look at the Chronarch 50MG, Curado'S D & BSF and some other Chronarchs I can't remember the model numbers for. After looking at Shimanos I got interested in the Scorpion's (to have something different--if they're good reels). I've been wanting a Lew's reel, and am leaning towards the BB1, BB1 Pro, or TP. I will eventually get a Shimano and a Lew's but can only afford 1 right now with $200 being my "limit". Any advice on which ones would suit my "needs" best?
I have 3 PQ's (that I have no problems with, one of the best deals in fishing at $69) and a Daiwa Tatula that I like a lot. Just want some other brands.
Curado I, E ,G - all good reels Citica E- good reel, will surprise you!! Chronarch B, D...awesome reels
Shimano, no doubt about it.
tomustang reply :
Look for a 50E, spool capacity is not an issue for 10-12lb line cranking. I see using 200s or lews sizes are better meant for bigger line
Dramer77 reply :
I just picked up a new curado I, amazing reel.. I had a lews bb1 and it's no match for the curado
FL Bass Abducter reply :
Maybe it's just me, but I have to have all my reels the same brand/model. I carry 8-10 rods with me and I don't like to pick up a rod and the feel and performance not be the same as the one I just set down on the deck. I keep hearing about the lews, but it's hard for me to stray away from Shimano because parts are readily available and I know how to strip them down to the frame with my eyes closed.
Rods are a different story as we all know you need different lengths/actions for different lures. 
cajunpapi reply :
Lamham3, flip a coin, they are both fantastic reels. You are going to get both eventually.
bradc36 reply :
I personally love my lew's reels. I own a couple TP's, MG's, superduty, all the way down to the regular speed spool and I've had no issues. My fishing buddy is loaded up with every shimano reel you could think of and I think he feels the same way. You can't go wrong with either.
TrapperJ reply :
Im a huge fan of Lew's heck even the $99 model is killer!
related Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
most viewed Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
© 2024 - fishing.qciss.net. All Rights Reserved.