fishing spot logo
fishing spot font logo



What's Everybody's Favorite Jerk Bait Excluding The Lucky Craft Pointer? 2024


fishing user avatarMatthew Veillion reply : 

I'm assuming ill get alot of people saying pointers anyways but, pointers are a bit too much for me, I'm still in high school and have no job, so i usually wont buy a lure over $10 plus ive never even used a jerk bait so i definitely wont pay for a pointer to start out. Just comment your favorites besides the lucky craft pointer.


fishing user avatargman2 reply : 

Smithwick- Rogues classic producing jerkbaits

Rapala-xrap nice baits for the money...

bass pro shops stuff don't look to bad...never used one personally


fishing user avataraavery2 reply : 

Academy Sports H2O baits are inexpensive and work well.  Rick Clunn STX jerbaits are good too, might need a hook change.


fishing user avatarHi Salenity reply : 

You may want to look at the Luck "E" Strike RC. I have one but havent fished it yet.


fishing user avatarww2farmer reply : 

Luck-E-Strike Rick Clunn Stx, Excaliber EEeratic shad are two that I tried and had good success with last year. With the RC Stx getting a slight nod for smallmouth, and the Excaliber seemed to be a better LM and pike bait. I will try the SK KVD's this coming season. I have always had the Spro Mcstick on my try list, but for some reason I have not yet. I was never a big fan of X-raps, I caught fish on them, but I got way too many duds right out of the package, baits that would sink like rocks, leak, float, etc....I did like the husky jerks though, and for many many years they were my go to suspending jerkbait.


fishing user avatarTeal reply : 

My favorite is a L**** C**** P****er. But I really like the Rapala XRap. I throw it a lot.

I did buy two of the Luck E Strike STX jerkbaits last month to see wht was all the fuss about, and it is a great jerkbait for 8 bucks. ( if any of y'all buy these, change the split rings and add quality hooks). I found out hard way. Otherwise a good bait.

Suggestion. Start out with the Smithwick Rogue. They are 5 bucks or so and they are proven baits.


fishing user avatarKYntucky Warmouth reply : 

I love the Owner Cultiva Rip'n Minnow 65 and 70 but they are getter more expensive and harder to come by. I also like the Damiki Striker 90, and Yo-Zuri Sashimi Jerkbait. For a good bait on a budget I'd say Bomber Long A, Spro McStick, Strike King Wild Shiner, or the classic Smithwick Rogue. I personally wouldn't pay $8 for the Luck-E-Strikes, they are $4 baits MAX...not worth it.


fishing user avatarbasseditor reply : 

I use the Bomber Long A most of the time. Second is Rogue.


fishing user avatarHi Salenity reply : 
  On 1/6/2013 at 11:47 AM, KYntucky Warmouth said:
I love the Owner Cultiva Rip'n Minnow 65 and 70 but they are getter more expensive and harder to come by. I also like the Damiki Striker 90, and Yo-Zuri Sashimi Jerkbait. For a good bait on a budget I'd say Bomber Long A, Spro McStick, Strike King Wild Shiner, or the classic Smithwick Rogue. I personally wouldn't pay $8 for the Luck-E-Strikes, they are $4 baits MAX...not worth it.

Why dont you think the LS is a $8 bait? Just courious...


fishing user avatarje1946 reply : 

Rapala x raps, BPS XPS pro series, Lucky Strike RC, I like the old Rebels, gotta tweak em a little with suspend dots or solder on the trebels, but if u can get em right the bass love em.


fishing user avatarretiredbosn reply : 

X2 on the H2O baits from Academy, every H2O bait I've tried perform very well, and the price is outstanding.


fishing user avatarBluebasser86 reply : 

Luck E Strike and Excaliber Erratic shad are my two favorite cheaper jerkbaits. The X rap is a good bait too but just doesn't seem to produce as well as other jerkbaits for me. 


fishing user avatarwisconsin heat reply : 

I had a lot of luck with the Spro Mcstick 95 this fall, a few bass every trip. Oh, and the pike liked it too :P


fishing user avatarTRYTOFISH reply : 

SPRO McSTICK IS MY FAVORITE.


fishing user avatarPrimus reply : 

Check your message box.


fishing user avatarDwight Hottle reply : 

Rapala husky jerk.


fishing user avatarshootermcbob reply : 

I have just started fishing with jerkbaits. That said, I caught the most fish on a pearl Rick Clunn lucky strike jerkbait, closely followed by a bone colored Eeratic shad jerkbait.


fishing user avatarBassThumb reply : 

I have caught more fish on the XRap than with any other jerkbait.


fishing user avatarMatthew Veillion reply : 

Im going to cabelas today and im going to pick up a few luck e strike rc stx jekrks


fishing user avatarKYntucky Warmouth reply : 
  On 1/6/2013 at 12:21 PM, Hi Salenity said:
Why dont you think the LS is a $8 bait? Just courious...

For me it's the overall quality of the bait. I don't like the hooks, saw one in the package that had a broken hook and, including the RC cranks, I've seen alot of shorty manufacturing...off center line tie, off aligned hooks, cracks in the body and bill. I just don't think the quality is there compared to others at that price, they're almost the same price as an X-rap and are far behind them in quality.


fishing user avatarthehooligan reply : 

Yozuri Pins minnow is the best jerkbait ive ever used followed by the xrap. I think the pointer is a great bait but overrated...


fishing user avatarVABassin'14 reply : 

The Excaliber Erratic Shads are great lures for the price. Hard bodied jerk baits are my absolute favorite kind of lures to throw and I have never spent over $10 on any of them. The Erratic Shads have great action and run true straight out of the box. Get a couple of them and you will be pleased with how well they perform. I am not a fan of X-Raps just because I have never done well with them but I know people who absolutely love them as well. There are definitely good options out there without have to spend the big bucks on jerk baits, but recommend the Excaliber Erratic Shad.  


fishing user avatarMCS reply : 

Diawa DB Minnow, Bomber Long A


fishing user avatarJrob78 reply : 

I like the XCalibur EEratic Shad, it's a great bait for the money.  The H20 baits are also really nice and the price can't be beat.  The only thing about their jerkbaits is the only one that suspends is the deep diving model.  The 2 shallow jerkbaits are floaters.  You might also check out the new Strike King KVD jerkbaits.  I haven't used or even bought one yet but they look awesome.  The color patterns are outstanding and it comes in 2 sizes.


fishing user avatarroadwarrior reply : 

Over the years, the Smithwick Rogue has been my biggest producer.


fishing user avatarRatherbfishing reply : 

 

  On 1/6/2013 at 11:54 PM, Dwight Hottle said:
Rapala husky jerk.
Was wondering if you could tell me what the difference in action between a deep diving husky jerk and a deep diving X-rap is? It's possible you've never used either (deep diving version, i mean) but maybe you knew...
fishing user avatarSilas reply : 
  On 1/9/2013 at 11:50 PM, roadwarrior said:
Over the years, the Smithwick Rogue has been my biggest producer.

 

Long ago....over 20 years or so, the Rogue in black back, gold side, orange bottom was THE bait at TOLEDO BEND, La./Tx.


fishing user avatarDwight Hottle reply : 
  On 1/10/2013 at 12:34 AM, Ratherbfishing said:
 Was wondering if you could tell me what the difference in action between a deep diving husky jerk and a deep diving X-rap is? It's possible you've never used either (deep diving version, i mean) but maybe you knew...

 

I use a lot of the deep diving huskies. Probably have two boxes of them. I use them to cover deeper water. They will run as deep as 17-18 feet on a long line, small dia braid. The husky deep divers & smithwick deep divers have a similar action but subtly  different.. I don't use the X-rap deep diver much. They have a more erratic action then the husky but are smaller in profile. The husky is better in colder water and the X-rap is better as a warmer water bait when the bass are more willing to chase.  


fishing user avatarpaul25 reply : 

the spro mcstick in the 110 and 95 and the husky jerk by rapala.


fishing user avatarlivetofish28 reply : 

Rogue


fishing user avatarGatorbassman reply : 

My favorite is still the Smithwick Rogue. Sometimes you have to play with them so they susspend right but when you get them right they catch fish.


fishing user avatarMaico1 reply : 

Wow, no one here using Vision 110's.....


fishing user avatarJay Ell Gee reply : 
  On 1/13/2013 at 11:16 PM, Maico1 said:
Wow, no one here using Vision 110's.....

If you missed it, the goal was to provide the OP with some ideas on jerkbaits that are cheaper to buy and learn on (lose) than pointers. The MB Vision 110 simply doesn't fit that criteria.


fishing user avatarriskkid 2 reply : 

Rogue but bought me a McStick to try out this year, they look good.


fishing user avatarHanover_Yakker reply : 

MirrOLures are pretty good good for me and have better color patterns that are more realistic than most. Koppers Live Target Herrings look pretty sweet. X-Raps are okay but the bills are very fragile.


fishing user avatarJrob78 reply : 
  On 1/13/2013 at 11:16 PM, Maico1 said:
Wow, no one here using Vision 110's.....

 

He said keep it at or under $10.


fishing user avatarRatherbfishing reply : 

 

  On 1/12/2013 at 7:50 AM, Dwight Hottle said:
I use a lot of the deep diving huskies. Probably have two boxes of them. I use them to cover deeper water. They will run as deep as 17-18 feet on a long line, small dia braid. The husky deep divers & smithwick deep divers have a similar action but subtly  different.. I don't use the X-rap deep diver much. They have a more erratic action then the husky but are smaller in profile. The husky is better in colder water and the X-rap is better as a warmer water bait when the bass are more willing to chase.  

Thank you sir!


fishing user avatarjbsoonerfan reply : 

Xcalibur EEratic


fishing user avatarJ Francho reply : 

You guys need to relax. Anyone can comment here.

  On 1/6/2013 at 11:10 AM, Matthew Veillion said:
I'm assuming ill get alot of people saying pointers anyways but, pointers are a bit too much for me, I'm still in high school and have no job, so i usually wont buy a lure over $10 plus ive never even used a jerk bait so i definitely wont pay for a pointer to start out. Just comment your favorites besides the lucky craft pointer.

LC Flash Minnow 115. You can find them used for about $12. At $8 - $10, X-raps are a rip off. The bill isn't durable, and 3/4 of them don't run right out of the box. Husky Jerks don't seem to have that problem. Smithwick Rogues are a good option if you don't want to spend too much.


fishing user avatar0119 reply : 

Snook tear up a jerk baits finish after just a few catches. I found the generic lure bodies that netcraft sells to be a economic alternative and you can put on your own preference of hook. The cost its low but color choices are limited. On the plus side there colors copy lucky crafts. Mirrorlure Mirrodines and Catch 2000 are good durable cheaper alternatives too as is the original Rebel Minnow.


fishing user avatarCPBassFishing reply : 

Definitely check out the daiwa DB minnow. Very good hooks, suspends perfectly, and it has great colors. Best feature? Its only $6. :)


fishing user avatarOkobojiEagle reply : 

The LC Pointer is one of those baits that you should save your nickels and dimes until you can afford to buy one... it's that good.

 

oe


fishing user avatarsenko_77 reply : 

I'm surprised no one on here has suggested the Rapala original floating minnow.  Once the water warms up a bit, that thing will get eaten when nothing else will.  Cast out, let the ripples settle, then one twitch.  Let the ripples settle again, then two twitches.  Repeat.  I've caught a ton of fish doing this.


fishing user avatarFishes in trees reply : 

I don't know about the rest of the country, but in Missouri, the tournament record of the Lucky Craft Pointer is unmatched.  The spring jerkbait window isn't open that long.  I'd go ahead and save my pennies for a few Lucky Craft Pointers.  

 

That being said, I hear about more and more guys each year throwing the Vision  110.




6748

related Fishing Tackle topic

Jitterbug size and color
Favorite shaky head worm?
Tackle for Cheap
What Buzzbait, What Size, And With Or Without A Clacker?
Icast Sneak Peek "rage Shellcracker"
48 Degree Water Temps - What Are Your Favorite Lures?
Cooler Talk!
The best lure
Looking for the *perfect* jig
JACK HAMMER SURPRISE
Your "go-to" bait when fishing is really good...???
Omgosh, How Many Crankbaits Do I Need???
Worm Fishing
10 Unbelievable Frog Blowups In Slow Motion
To What Extent Do You Wear Uv Protective Clothing?
HELP! Am I terrible at fishing? Or is it my location?
Your favorite Lures and rigs
What is the WORST BAIT?
Why I Use A Leader ......
What are you going to try in the new year?



previous topic
What Is That One Lure That Always Catches Fish For You? -- Fishing Tackle
next topic
Jitterbug size and color -- Fishing Tackle