Choices, choices, choices. 2024
Raider Nation Fisher reply :
So I'm finally shelling out some money on a new reel. Going to the BPS spring classic so as not to break the bank on one. I want to stay spend no more than 200 dollars. Currently I'm torn between the Quantum Pt Smoke and one of the Revo reels. Y'all got any input or suggestions for me?
SausageFingers23 reply :
Personally, I'm a Revo guy. I love them. The SX is a workhorse and is great to fish. I don't have any experience with the Quantum line.
You might want to consider the Pro Quailifier. Its a solid reel, comes in a number of different gear ratios, and runs about $100. You could grab two or save some and pick up other things that you need/want.
adclem reply :
I would go with the Revos STX or Revo SX or even the Patriarch. The Curados are also an excellent choice to consider.
Later, 
BASSclary reply :
Advantage HSTA or SHIMANO Curado
WanderLust reply :
QuoteAdvantage HSTA or SHIMANO Curado
^^^
Excellent choices. Just added a Curado 51E to my collection. My fishing partner has the Advantage... Extremely nice forn the money.
bwell reply :
You cant go wrong with the Revo STX... Its by far my favorite reel.
Bass_Fanatic reply :
IMHO, you cant go wrong with any reel over $150...they are all quality reels and it comes down to personal preference.
Now, after saying that, get the Pflueger President...its teh best ;D ;D ;D
ww2farmer reply :
QuoteY'all got any input or suggestions for me?
Hmmmm...........being a raiders fan, there is not too much I can say that will make sense to you, brain damage of that magnitude is irreversible.
dave reply :
Wait for it...
Quitlimpin reply :
Have been an Abu Garcia guy all my life. Took the shimano plunge last summer and picked up an e7. Long story short...all but one sx have been sold/traded for curados. IMHO, it's a no brainer---curado owns the $200 & under reels
shimanogloomis man reply :
QuoteAdvantage HSTA or SHIMANO Curado
im a shimano guy obviousy ;D and my twin bro is a diawa guy so he has a hsta and i have a e7 while the diawas is a little smother i preferred the e7 let me tell you why 1st its lighter,casts better casting and pitching, fits in my hand better,drags stronger and im a big fan of the larger knobs hope this helps
Raider Nation Fisher reply :
Wow a raider hater on the site. Who'd have thought. Anyway. Never put much thought to Shimanos reels. I've personally always fished Okumas. I'm just not real big on their new higher end reels. After all through talk about the Shimanos reels, I might have to try one. However she who must be obeyed has given me permission to spend another hundred and fifty so my limit is now 350. Would that be overkill on a reel or should I stay in the 200 range.
WanderLust reply :
QuoteWow a raider hater on the site. Who'd have thought. Anyway. Never put much thought to Shimanos reels. I've personally always fished Okumas. I'm just not real big on their new higher end reels. After all through talk about the Shimanos reels, I might have to try one. However she who must be obeyed has given me permission to spend another hundred and fifty so my limit is now 350. Would that be overkill on a reel or should I stay in the 200 range.
That puts you in range for a ton of sick reels however $200 will get you a great reel.
BASSclary reply :
for $350 get a Daiwa Zillion, or SHIMANO Core, and blow the rest on tackle.
BassThumb reply :
In my opinion, there's no need to spend $350 on a single reel. You can get two Shimano Curados or Revo STXs for less than that on eBay from retailers with the Buy It Now option. These two reels will not hold you back whatsoever, and I believe you'll catch more fish with two very good combos than you will with one great combo.
There's an online flea market that has a brand new 2009 Revo STX-HS on sale right now for $140. I'll PM you with details.
Gone_Phishin reply :
What are your intentions for this reel? Plastics and jigs? Cranks? Topwater? Spinnerbaits?
central.PA.bass reply :
nothin' better than a good which reel is better than the other thread...
REVO STX
Raider Nation Fisher reply :
QuoteWhat are your intentions for this reel? Plastics and jigs? Cranks? Topwater? Spinnerbaits?
Im going to say mostly cranks. If it will do cranks and top waters that would be a huge plus. Still mostly if not all cranks.
Fat-G reply :
QuoteQuoteAdvantage HSTA or SHIMANO Curadoim a shimano guy obviousy ;D and my twin bro is a diawa guy so he has a hsta and i have a e7 while the diawas is a little smother i preferred the e7 let me tell you why 1st its lighter,casts better casting and pitching, fits in my hand better,drags stronger and im a big fan of the larger knobs
hope this helps
That's the second person that has told you that. 
WanderLust reply :
QuoteQuoteWhat are your intentions for this reel? Plastics and jigs? Cranks? Topwater? Spinnerbaits?Im going to say mostly cranks. If it will do cranks and top waters that would be a huge plus. Still mostly if not all cranks.
Shimano CU200E5 is the right reel for the job. Probably one of the best crankbait reels around especially for the price.
bwell reply :
If you are going to be using it for cranks then I would either get the Revo winch or the Shimano curado e5... I haven't used either of them but from the reviews from others the curado is the way to go for a low gear ratio casting reel. I will be looking into getting a curado e5 next month.
B A S S E R reply :
You can buy 3 Pro Qualifiers's at the classic for a little over $200 if you do the reel trade in. They are on sale for $80 a piece and you get $10 off each one when you trade in. They are awesome reels and come in 4 different gear ratios.
WanderLust reply :
QuoteIf you are going to be using it for cranks then I would either get the Revo winch or the Shimano curado e5... I haven't used either of them but from the reviews from others the curado is the way to go for a low gear ratio casting reel. I will be looking into getting a curado e5 next month.
I have a Curado 201E7 and a Revo Winch. If Shimano would have made a 201E5 I would have that as well. Instead I have the 51E which is a great light bait reel.
bpNClgmouth reply :
Just got my Quantum Smoke 7:0:1 and paired it with the new Powell Endurance 723....couldn't be happier
ChiCityBasser reply :
Of the reels you asked about I would go with the Quantum Smoke with the Abu being my second choice. Get a feel for the reel on a comparable rod and read some of the reviews.
BigGame0892 reply :
The Curado 200E5 no doubt for cranking. Love mine and want 2 more. They can be had on eBay for $140 or less. Assuming you have rods for multiple reels, get one E5 and one E7 and you'll be set for a lot of different stuff.
Raider Nation Fisher reply :
Thanks to all y'all (well except maybe the raider hater, jealousy pure jealousy ;D) for all the suggestions and advice. Y'all have definately given me some things to think about. I knew there was a reason I liked this site so much. ;
NorcalBassin reply :
No reason to go >$200 on a CB reel. Not going to find anything better than that E5 for your planned application anyway. Be careful with the smoke... could be more smoke and mirrors than anything- reviews pretty mixed thus far.
Nibbles reply :
Quotefor $350 get a Daiwa Zillion, or SHIMANO Core, and blow the rest on tackle.
As much a Daiwa fan as I am, I would still never, ever, ever, ever pay full price for a Zillion.
As much as I hate to admit it, if you're looking for a good cranking reel, Daiwa's USDM currently has diddly squat. If you're willing to go after an aftermarket Sol or Alphas though, they're pretty nice for most cranking applications.
flippin and pitchin reply :
QuoteThanks to all y'all (well except maybe the raider hater, jealousy pure jealousy ;D) for all the suggestions and advice. Y'all have definately given me some things to think about. I knew there was a reason I liked this site so much. ;
There are two things you always count on with this forum; Suggestions and Confusion. Get something black and silver for sure.
related Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
most viewed Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
© 2024 - fishing.qciss.net. All Rights Reserved.