Rank These Reels 2024
Carterjig68 reply :
Hey I've got some reels and was wondering if you could rank them from best to worst. Not for any particular technique but the quality in general. The reels are as follows.
Shimano Curado 200e7
Shimano Chronarch 200e7
Shimano Chronarch ci4+
Shimano Scorpion HG
Lews BB1 pro speed spool
EvanT123 reply :
You have the reels. Why not rank them for us?
Jrob78 reply :
They are all quality reels. Ranking them would be pointless and subjective at best.
Carterjig68 reply :
For me they are fairly new so it would be hard to rank them so early but I wanted to hear others opinions on it
new2BC4bass reply :
Keep in mind this is a 14 year old youngster, so take it easy on him 
Only reel on that list that I have is a Curado 201E7. I like it a lot.......a whole lot. From the reading I've done on those reels I would say likes and dislikes are going to vary based on an individual's preferences. Not a bad one in the bunch. 
iabass8 reply :
Steak > Chinese food > Stuffed Shells > Pizza > Peanut Butter Captain Crunch
MIbassyaker reply :
Every one of those reels is nicer than anything I have. Whichever one gets ranked lowest, I'll be happy to take it off your hands...
EvanT123 reply :
True enough, sometimes it's hard to tell on the mobile version because the avitars are so small.On 12/1/2015 at 10:08 AM, new2BC4bass said:Keep in mind this is a 14 year old youngster, so take it easy on him
Op it sounds like your trying to figure out what to buy. As stated before you would probably not be disappointed with any of those choices.
buzzed bait reply :
VERY subjective topic here, but i'll play.... and this is merely my opinion. HOWEVER you rank them, it's one killer collection for a youngster or anyone for that matter! congratulations on a fine stable of reels you have there.
i do own the curado 201e and the chronarch ci4+ 151
1. Shimano Chronarch ci4+
2. Lews BB1 pro speed spool
3. Shimano Scorpion HG
4. Shimano Chronarch 200e7
5. Shimano Curado 200e7
South FLA reply :
1. Shimano Chronarch ci4+
2. Shimano Scorpion HG (JDM version of new model Curado, with I believe two extra bearings and cool burgundy color)
3a. Shimano Chronarch 200e7
3b. Shimano Curado 200e7 
4. Lews BB1 pro speed spool 
I have own, owned, or tried all the above mentioned reels, the rubber thumb-bar covering will eventually fail on the CI4+ and its annoying, Curado E7 is a proven performer and highly sought after, I sold a new in box one not to long ago for a premium over what I paid for it!
QUAKEnSHAKE reply :
1. Shimano Chronarch ci4+
2. Shimano Scorpion HG
3. Shimano Curado 200e7
4. Shimano Chronarch 200e7
5. Lews BB1 pro speed spool
Carterjig68 reply :
VERY subjective topic here, but i'll play.... and this is merely my opinion. HOWEVER you rank them, it's one killer collection for a youngster or anyone for that matter! congratulations on a fine stable of reels you have there.
i do own the curado 201e and the chronarch ci4+ 151
Thank you, I've been working on building the quantity and quality of my reels for a while. and that is about what I'd rank them so far. Except id rank the Curado higher just because I've tried for so long to get it and it is supertuned.
soflabasser reply :
They are all good reels and will get the job done.Let him choose the one he wants.
tomustang reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 10:10 AM, iabass8 said:Steak > Chinese food > Stuffed Shells > Pizza > Peanut Butter Captain Crunch
Substitute stuff shells with shellfish and you got the list
iabass8 reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 12:36 PM, tomustang said:Substitute stuff shells with shellfish and you got the list
Blasphemy!
MIbassyaker reply :
shellfish > steak
Sorry, it's true.
k3bass reply :
How can you guys rate the curado or chronarch E's at different ratings? Aren't they the same reel?
iabass8 reply :
.On 12/1/2015 at 12:43 PM, MIbassyaker said:shellfish > steak
Sorry, it's true.
iabass8 reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 12:43 PM, MIbassyaker said:shellfish > steak
Sorry, it's true.
Said no man ever. Grab your purse and head back to the martini bar!
Mike L reply :
Youngster...
Look, regardless of some of the playing around, the majority of the guys here would salavate all over themselves (I know I would) if they had a choice of reels to use that you have..you're very lucky.
Now, IMHO They are all quality reels that will give you years of use, so no problem choosing there...
They are all basically the same size so you'll have to fish each to see which feels better to you for a long day...
Check the spool sizes you have, don't use a smaller spool one which will carry less line if you plan on bombing big crank or hard swim baits...
Lastly, compare the reel speed of each for what you want to do..
A high speed reel, 6:5.1 or higher are best used for presentations that you'd want to take up line as quick as you can.
For me that means anything thrown on top, or on the bottom.
Good Luck, and go have some fun.
Mike
Choporoz reply :
Out of curiosity, why do you ask? What will you do when you get them 'ranked' by 'us'?
Puggz reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 9:26 AM, Carterjig68 said:Hey I've got some reels and was wondering if you could rank them from best to worst. Not for any particular technique but the quality in general. The reels are as follows.
Shimano Curado 200e7
Shimano Chronarch 200e7
Shimano Chronarch ci4+
Shimano Scorpion HG
Lews BB1 pro speed spool
Ranking best to worst is totally subjective as already mentioned here. Go out and use them and you'll find your favorites. Price/quality/reputation are all pointless if you don't like it. Now if you were shopping for a new reel your question would be more valid as others can give you a place to start.
My experience - I have both Chronarch models you mention. I don't care for the 200e7 at all. Actually, I prefer my Daiwa Tatula-100 that costs 1/2 as much as the Shimano. My Tatula type R smokes the 200e7 which i find comparible to the Ci4 (which I like except for the price)
Why don't you tell us what you think? Your experience, preference, and why....
South FLA reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 11:47 PM, Puggz said:Ranking best to worst is totally subjective as already mentioned here. Go out and use them and you'll find your favorites. Price/quality/reputation are all pointless if you don't like it. Now if you were shopping for a new reel your question would be more valid as others can give you a place to start.
My experience - I have both Chronarch models you mention. I don't care for the 200e7 at all. Actually, I prefer my Daiwa Tatula-100 that costs 1/2 as much as the Shimano. My Tatula type R smokes the 200e7 which i find comparible to the Ci4 (which I like except for the price)
Why don't you tell us what you think? Your experience, preference, and why....
I am with you on the Tatula, outcast, smooth, great drag and you can get them for about $140 on sale! That is why I sold a new in box 200e7 and bought 2 New Type Rs!
QUAKEnSHAKE reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 1:30 PM, k3bass said:How can you guys rate the curado or chronarch E's at different ratings? Aren't they the same reel?
no, there are differences that may sway a person to prefer one over the other
Jaderose reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 10:49 PM, Mike L said:Youngster...
Look, regardless of some of the playing around, the majority of the guys here would salavate all over themselves (I know I would) if they had a choice of reels to use that you have..you're very lucky.
Now, IMHO They are all quality reels that will give you years of use, so no problem choosing there...
They are all basically the same size so you'll have to fish each to see which feels better to you for a long day...
Check the spool sizes you have, don't use a smaller spool one which will carry less line if you plan on bombing big crank or hard swim baits...
Lastly, compare the reel speed of each for what you want to do..
A high speed reel, 6:5.1 or higher are best used for presentations that you'd want to take up line as quick as you can.
For me that means anything thrown on top, or on the bottom.
Good Luck, and go have some fun.
Mike
This. You're set, Partner. All are better than anything I got. The best one is the one you enjoy fishing with the most.
k3bass reply :
On 12/2/2015 at 12:02 AM, QUAKEnSHAKE said:no, there are differences that may sway a person to prefer one over the other
What are the differences besides the 6.4 gear ratio option? I've owned a few curado and citica E's, but never had any chronarch E's.
tomustang reply :
On 12/2/2015 at 1:08 AM, k3bass said:What are the differences besides the 6.4 gear ratio option? I've owned a few curado and citica E's, but never had any chronarch E's.
The chronarch has half a carbon drag, it cant support dual bearings per knob compared to the curado
Carterjig68 reply :
The reason I wanted them ranked was to hear the opinions of others and to see what they like the best and the worst. Just wanted to hear what others think. personally, I'd rank them as follows
chronarch ci4
Curado 200e7 (it is supertuned)
scorpion
bb1
chronarch 200e7
mrpao reply :
To me all those reels are about equal. Its a matter a preference.
I have owned all those reels. With the exception of the scorpion which is really the same as a curado 200hg. Which i have also owned.
Performance will vary from reel to reel and brand to brand.
I've had stock reels that preform better than super tuned ones. It just depends on the reel.
All those are great reels and should give you very little trouble down the road
fishballer06 reply :
On 12/1/2015 at 11:41 AM, QUAKEnSHAKE said:1. Shimano Chronarch ci4+
2. Shimano Scorpion HG
3. Shimano Curado 200e7
4. Shimano Chronarch 200e7
5. Lews BB1 pro speed spool
This.
related Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
previous topic
most viewed Fishing Rods Reels Line Knots topic
© 2024 - fishing.qciss.net. All Rights Reserved.