fishing spot logo
fishing spot font logo



What's Your Choice Out Of These Lures? 2024


fishing user avatartcbass reply : 

1.)  Crankbait/jerkbait or Spinnerbait?

 

 

 

2.)  Jig or  stickbait/creature bait?

 

 

 

***    It's not about what group you choose.

 

 

It's like out of question 1, of the two, which would you choose, and then out out of question 2, of the two, which would you choose.


fishing user avatarmerc1997 reply : 

each have a time and place.

 

bo


fishing user avatarMichaelJ7 reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 6:58 AM, merc1997 said:

each have a time and place.

bo

^^^X2. However for year round results personally if say option two. Of course I'd feel like I lost an arm if I couldn't do all of the above


fishing user avatartcbass reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 6:58 AM, merc1997 said:

each have a time and place.

 

bo

I know. But the point is that you have to make a choice. lol.


fishing user avatarDavid D. reply : 

I'll take group 2 if I have to choose.


fishing user avatarIAY reply : 

I'd take group 1 if I can only fish one, since I don't find joy in fishing group 2.


fishing user avatarChris9999 reply : 

Out of those I would generally say spinner bait and the second one I am more iffy about. I have more confidence with the jig but Ive been trying to catch more on stickbaits recently.


fishing user avatarYourBassIsGrass reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 9:22 AM, IAY said:

I'd take group 1 if I can only fish one, since I don't find joy in fishing group 2.

Do you not find joy in group 2 because of the pace of fishing, the strike of the fish on those baits, or because of lack of success? Not trying to highjack, just curious as to how you found your way to preferring group 1 over group 2.


fishing user avatartcbass reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 9:22 AM, IAY said:

I'd take group 1 if I can only fish one, since I don't find joy in fishing group 2.

 

 

It's not about what group you choose.

 

 

It's like out of question 1, of the two, which would you choose, and then out out of question 2, of the two, which would you choose.


fishing user avatarQUAKEnSHAKE reply : 

1. spinnerbait

 

2. stick/creature

 

OVERALL.  creature (kinami palm tree)


fishing user avatarIAY reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 9:46 AM, tcbass said:

It's not about what group you choose.

 

 

It's like out of question 1, of the two, which would you choose, and then out out of question 2, of the two, which would you choose.

I think you should edit this into your original post since it clarifies your question a lot.

 

I would choose crankbait out of group 1 because its very effective in multiple conditions, and jig from group 2 since it catches bigger fish consistently.


fishing user avatarsparky241 reply : 

I guess I have too choose column 1


fishing user avatarCatch and Grease reply : 

Group one defiantly crankbaits and in group two I'd take the stickbait with the jig really close...


fishing user avatareinscodek reply : 
  On 5/29/2014 at 6:58 AM, merc1997 said:

each have a time and place.

 

bo

X2


fishing user avatarMr. BattleArmor reply : 

1) jerkbait

2) jig

 

just based off of personal success


fishing user avatarPersicoTrotaVA reply : 

That's tough...3 years ago I would have gone Spinnerbait and creature but today I would have to say crankbait and jig.  Crankbaits are my #1 confidence bait and I am trying to be a better jig fisherman.


fishing user avataraavery2 reply : 

Crankbait and a Jig for me.


fishing user avatarDavid D. reply : 

1. Spinnerbait

2. Stick bait / creature


fishing user avatarnascar2428 reply : 

Spinnerbait/Soft stick bait


fishing user avatarjignfule reply : 

Not my choice, It's the basses choice.


fishing user avatarBigKev77 reply : 

DON'T MAKE ME CHOOSE!!! If I have to.

 

Group one: I HATE crankbaits but because of that I have been forcing myself to use them. So, reluctantly, I have to chose a squarebill crankbait.

 

Group two: If there is a jig in my tacklebox it WILL be tied on before I hit the water.

 

If they aren't getting the job done you change. Where I fish I think those two are the best bet to get started.


fishing user avatarhb2392 reply : 

Jerkbait & Stick


fishing user avatarhatrix reply : 

I would for sure pick a crank from group 1.

A year or 2 ago I would of picked the jig from 2. Now a days I just can't get away from D-Bombs an tubes.


fishing user avatarArv reply : 

All, and others


fishing user avatarBassintheweeds reply : 

if vibrating jig is included under jig.

 

Jig.


fishing user avatarFish Murderer 71 reply : 

Stickbait, jerkbait, jig, crankbait, spinnerbait. in that order


fishing user avatarMCS reply : 

1. Spinnerbait

 

2. Creature

 

Very confident in both and out of all the techniques my favorite two.


fishing user avatarBassWhole! reply : 

Wow, talk about a broken arrow...


fishing user avatarskeletor6 reply : 

1. Spinner bait

2. Jig

For versatility alone. Switch your trailer on the jig and spinnerbait and you can accomplish many things.


fishing user avatariceintheveins reply : 

1. Spinnerbait

2. Jig


fishing user avatarCatt reply : 

#1 creature Rage Tail Space Monkey

#2 spinner bait Stanley Vibra Wedge


fishing user avatarCalBassin reply : 

In group 1 I'd choose the crankbait. All because crankbaits are one of my confidence baits. I've caught so many fish on crankbaits and you can always use them in a variety of ways. People say that the spinner bait is the best search bait there is but in my opinion I think of a square bill or a rattle trap a search bait as well. All n all crankbaits are more versatile in my humble opinion.

In group 2 I'd obviously choose the jig because of how jigs just flat out catch fish. A jig can be fished ANYWHERE and with the right trailer you better set that hook because you'll have big mamas knocking at your boat.




8093

related Fishing Tackle topic

New To Soft Plastics Fishing
Best Rapala Dt6 Color For Clear And Dark Water?
Bending down the barb on a hook
LEARNING JIGS
Beaver/creature Vs Worms
Jig fishing in wind or rain
Soft Plastic colors
Difference between shakey head and jig?
favorite shakey head bait??
Favorite Lipless Crankbait Color?
Is Tungsten Really Worth It???
Basspro Shops Soft Plastics
Favorite Soft Plastics?
What's your favorite worm and worm hook
Aaron Martens Lure
I'm Done...
Soooo many paddle tail swimbaits!!
Inexpensive Polarized Shade Help.
Just Went To Tackle Warehouse
in search of larger soft creature baits.



previous topic
Tackle Giveaway For The Younger Members! -- Fishing Tackle
next topic
New To Soft Plastics Fishing -- Fishing Tackle